New York vs. Chicago, USA: Best Christmas City Guide

Introduction

When it comes to celebrating Christmas in the U.S., New York City and Chicago are two of the most iconic destinations. Each city transforms into a festive wonderland, offering unique holiday experiences from dazzling lights to famous Christmas markets. Whether you’re drawn to the glitz and glamour of New York’s Rockefeller Center or the charm of Chicago’s Christkindlmarket, both cities offer an unforgettable holiday experience. But how do they compare? In this article, we’ll explore the highlights of each city during Christmas, from their history, location, and cost of living to their holiday attractions and Christmas markets.

New York at Christmas

History and Location

Founded in 1624, New York City is a global hub for finance, culture, and entertainment. Located on the East Coast, NYC is home to over 8.6 million people, making it the largest city in the U.S. Known for its towering skyscrapers and vibrant neighborhoods, New York transforms into a magical winter destination during the holiday season.

Christmas Spirit and Decorations

New York’s Christmas spirit is iconic. The city becomes a spectacle of twinkling lights, with Rockefeller Center being the centerpiece. Every year, millions of visitors flock to see the Rockefeller Christmas Tree, an 80-foot-tall spruce adorned with 50,000 LED lights. Fifth Avenue’s department stores also contribute to the festive atmosphere with their lavish window displays.

Must-Visit Christmas Attractions in New York

Rockefeller Center – Home to the famous Christmas tree and ice-skating rink.
Bryant Park Winter Village – A European-style Christmas market and ice rink.
Radio City Christmas Spectacular – A beloved holiday performance by the Rockettes.
Central Park Carriage Rides – Experience the magic of a horse-drawn carriage through snowy Central Park.
Dyker Heights – Famous for its extravagant Christmas light displays in Brooklyn.

Must-Try Christmas Foods in New York

Roasted Chestnuts – A classic street food during the holidays.
Hot Chocolate from Jacques Torres – A rich, velvety treat perfect for chilly winter days.
Christmas Cookies from Levain Bakery – Delicious, gooey cookies baked fresh.
New York Bagels with Christmas-themed toppings – Festive red and green cream cheese.
Eggnog – A festive drink often served at restaurants and holiday parties.

Best Christmas Activities in New York

Ice-skating at Rockefeller Center.
Watching the Macy’s Thanksgiving Day Parade kick off the Christmas season.
Visiting the holiday window displays along Fifth Avenue.
Enjoying a Christmas Eve stroll through Central Park.
Taking a Christmas-themed Harbor Lights Cruise.

Celebrities Who Spend Christmas in New York

Mariah Carey – The queen of Christmas often spends the holidays in NYC.
Sarah Jessica Parker – A New York resident who enjoys the festive season in the city.
Neil Patrick Harris – Frequently spotted enjoying holiday events in New York.
Taylor Swift – Has shared her love for New York’s Christmas magic.
Alec Baldwin – A long-time New York resident who celebrates Christmas in the city.

Chicago at Christmas

History and Location

Founded in 1837, Chicago is known for its architecture, cultural institutions, and Midwestern charm. With a population of 2.7 million, Chicago is the third-largest city in the U.S. Located along Lake Michigan, Chicago is often referred to as the “Windy City”, but it embraces winter weather, especially during the holiday season.

Christmas Spirit and Decorations

Chicago’s Christmas spirit is just as vibrant as New York’s. The city’s streets are filled with festive lights, especially along Magnificent Mile and in Millennium Park. Christkindlmarket is one of Chicago’s standout holiday events, bringing the tradition of a German Christmas market to the city. Visitors can explore charming wooden stalls filled with handmade crafts, ornaments, and holiday treats.

Must-Visit Christmas Attractions in Chicago

Christkindlmarket – A traditional German Christmas market with unique gifts and foods.
Millennium Park Ice Skating – A picturesque skating rink with views of the city skyline.
The Magnificent Mile – A famous shopping street decorated with twinkling lights.
ZooLights at Lincoln Park Zoo – A dazzling light display with holiday-themed activities.
Holiday Train on the “L” – A decorated CTA train that spreads holiday cheer throughout the city.

Must-Try Christmas Foods in Chicago

Glühwein – A spiced, warm wine served at the Christkindlmarket.
Chicago-style Pizza – Enjoyed year-round, but a holiday favorite among locals and visitors.
Hot Apple Cider – A winter drink sold at Christmas markets.
Pretzels from Christkindlmarket – Freshly baked and warm during the cold winter months.
Pfeffernüsse Cookies – Traditional spiced German Christmas cookies.

Best Christmas Activities in Chicago

Ice skating at Millennium Park with views of the city skyline.
Visiting the Christkindlmarket for authentic German holiday goods.
Strolling along The Magnificent Mile for Christmas shopping and lights.
Exploring ZooLights at Lincoln Park Zoo with its stunning displays.
Riding the CTA Holiday Train, a festively decorated train on the “L” tracks.

Celebrities Who Spend Christmas in Chicago

Oprah Winfrey – Formerly based in Chicago, Oprah still visits during the holiday season.
Jennifer Hudson – A Chicago native, Hudson often returns to the city for Christmas.
Vince Vaughn – Another Chicago native who enjoys spending time in the city during the holidays.
Chance the Rapper – Known for supporting local holiday events in his hometown.
Bill Murray – Frequently spotted in Chicago, enjoying the city’s festive spirit.

Comparison: New York vs. Chicago for Christmas

Christmas Markets

New York: Boasts several famous markets like the Bryant Park Winter Village, which offers a mix of food, holiday gifts, and ice skating.
Chicago: Home to the Christkindlmarket, a German-inspired market that has become a holiday staple with its festive atmosphere and unique offerings.

Christmas Decorations

New York: Known for its Rockefeller Christmas Tree and lavish decorations along Fifth Avenue. The Dyker Heights neighborhood is a must-visit for those who love extravagant Christmas lights.
Chicago: Features breathtaking light displays on The Magnificent Mile and the iconic ZooLights at Lincoln Park Zoo.

Cost of Living and Visitors

New York: Christmas in New York can be expensive, with the city being one of the most costly places to live and visit. However, its festive atmosphere attracts millions of visitors each holiday season, including 5 million just to see the Rockefeller Center tree.
Chicago: While still a major city, Chicago tends to be more affordable than New York, making it an attractive option for budget-conscious travelers. The Christkindlmarket alone draws in over 1 million visitors annually.

Must-Try Christmas Foods

Both cities offer delicious holiday treats, with New York’s roasted chestnuts and Christmas cookies rivaling Chicago’s pretzels and glühwein from the Christkindlmarket.

Quality of Life

Both cities offer an excellent holiday atmosphere, but Chicago’s affordability and Midwestern hospitality might make it more approachable for some visitors, while New York’s iconic landmarks make it a dream destination for those seeking a grand holiday experience.

Conclusion

Both New York and Chicago provide magical experiences during the Christmas season, each offering its unique blend of holiday spirit, attractions, and festive food. While New York dazzles with its world-famous decorations and bustling holiday markets, Chicago’s cozy, charming atmosphere and German-inspired Christkindlmarket offer an equally memorable holiday. Whether you’re looking for a grand spectacle or a warm and inviting holiday retreat, both cities have something special to offer.

Engage with Us

Which city do you think has the best Christmas spirit—New York or Chicago? Share your experiences in the comments below and join the conversation on social media!

Inbound Link Suggestions:

Outbound Link Suggestions: